# Solution Selection Kit

> A complete method to select technology vendors: five stages, five gates, three workbooks, four decks, 11 templates and a guide, worked through for one selection.

Source: https://ciohelm.com/toolkits/solution-selection-kit · Area: Decide · Price and packs: https://ciohelm.com/llms.txt

Most regretted technology choices were made early: a vague need, a favourite vendor, criteria set after the answers arrived, and a price that left out half the cost. This kit gives you one fair, defensible way to choose: five stages, five gates, scoring rules fixed before the market answers, and every template you need, filled in for a worked example.

Excel, PowerPoint and Word files. Yours to use and adapt inside your organisation.

## 19 working files, not a slide pack to read

Every file is editable and comes with a worked example for one fictional company, so you start from something, not from a blank page. Workbooks calculate as you type.

### Solution selection workbook (Excel)

22 sheets that run one selection: track and steps, plan and gates with a calculated recommendation, team and declarations of interest, requirements, the evaluation model with anchored scales, longlist and knock-out tests, RFI scoring, requirement responses and knock-outs, panel scores with calibration, demonstrations, proof of concept, references, due diligence, five-year cost, negotiation, the ranking at each step with a sensitivity test, risks and the decision log. A dashboard pulls it together.

### Vendor response workbook (RFP) (Excel)

The file every shortlisted vendor answers: instructions, context, 40 requirements with response codes, technology, implementation and company questions, references, questions and the declaration. It contains no prices.

### Vendor pricing workbook (sealed) (Excel)

The separate price file each vendor returns sealed: subscriptions, add-ons, implementation, training and support over five years, with the price terms and assumptions behind them. It is opened only after quality is scored.

### Selection framework overview (PowerPoint)

15 slides to get the method adopted: the framework on a page, eight principles, the stages, gates, scoring model, response codes, three tracks, roles and timeline.

### Evaluation results and finalists (PowerPoint)

10 slides for gate S3, worked through: the funnel, functional fit, panel scores, written ranking, demonstrations and the proof of concept plan.

### Award recommendation (PowerPoint)

11 slides for the award decision: recommendation, process safeguards, final ranking and sensitivity, proof of concept, references and due diligence, five-year cost, negotiation and risks.

### Vendor briefing deck (PowerPoint)

8 slides to brief every vendor at once: scope, dates, published weights, rules of engagement and what to send.

### Selection charter (Word)

Purpose, scope, envelope, track, principles, team, gates and the declaration of interests.

### Need, outcomes and current state (Word)

The need as outcomes with baselines, the work as it is done today, and the buy, reuse or build check.

### Market scan and longlist guide (Word)

Where to look, knock-out tests, the RFI and how to choose a shortlist you can defend.

### Request for information (RFI) (Word)

A short questionnaire vendors can answer in two to three days, with its scoring criteria.

### RFP instructions to vendors (Word)

Outcomes, timetable, what to submit, published weights, rules of engagement and commercial terms.

### Evaluator scoring guide (Word)

Anchored scales for every criterion, how to score alone and how the panel calibrates.

### Demo script and proof of concept plan (Word)

Scripted scenarios with sample data, then the proof of concept tests, critical tests and results.

### Reference call guide (Word)

How to choose reference clients and the questions that reveal problems, with scoring.

### Due diligence checklist (Word)

Security, privacy, resilience, financial and contract checks, with the evidence to ask for.

### Negotiation plan (Word)

Position, fallback, and every term with its opening ask, target and walk-away.

### Award memo and vendor letters (Word)

The award memo, award and regret letters, debriefs and the hand-over to delivery.

### Selecting technology without regret (Guide)

How to use the method, scale it, score fairly and avoid the common mistakes.

## Solution selection workbook, sheet by sheet

The workbook carries the method: scores, choices and plans calculate as you type, and the dashboard and deck figures come from it. Click any image to see it full size.

**Dashboard**: Stage, next gate, preferred vendor, its lead and cost against the envelope, and the funnel.

**Response fit**: Each vendor&#x27;s answer to every requirement, the weighted fit and the knock-outs.

**Scoring**: Panel scores by evaluator, spreads to discuss and the agreed score with its reason.

**Ranking**: The ranking after written responses, demonstrations and the proof of concept, with sensitivity.

## A ranking that would survive a challenge

Criteria and weights are locked before the RFP. A must answered "on roadmap" excludes a vendor, even the cheapest. Panels score alone, then agree, and the reason is recorded. Price is opened after quality, scored on five-year cost, and the ranking is tested against the price weight. In the sample, twelve vendors become one award, and every step shows why.

## The method, step by step

### Week 1 · Frame

Write the need as outcomes, check reuse, agree the envelope and the track, name the team.

### Weeks 2-5 · Scan

Scan the market wide, apply knock-out tests, run a short RFI, choose the shortlist and lock the criteria.

### Weeks 6-12 · Compete and prove

RFP, independent scoring, scripted demonstrations, then a proof of concept, references and due diligence.

### Weeks 13-16 · Commit

Negotiate with two finalists, write the award memo, award, debrief and hand over to delivery.

### Who it is for

- CIOs and heads of IT about to choose a platform, a SaaS product or an implementation partner
- IT sourcing and procurement leads who want business and technical rigour in the process
- Business owners leading a selection with IT
- Advisers running a selection for a client (one licence per client organisation)

### What you need

Excel, PowerPoint and Word, or compatible software. A light selection takes four to eight weeks; a strategic one four to six months.

### Free guide on this topic

- [Software selection without regret](https://ciohelm.com/guides/software-selection)

## Questions about the kit

**Does it replace our procurement policy?**

No. It adds the business and technical rigour that most policies assume but do not describe. If you are bound by public procurement law, follow it first; the principles here are consistent with it.

**Is it too heavy for a small purchase?**

No. Choose the light track and the workbook shows the steps you need: no RFI, a short RFP or quote request, demonstrations and references. The gates and principles stay the same.

**Can we use our own criteria and weights?**

Yes. Sections, criteria, weights, scales, response codes and the quality and price split are all set on the Criteria and Setup sheets. Lock them before the RFP goes out.

**Are the vendors in the example real?**

No. Vendor A to L and Partner X, Y and Z are fictional, as is the manufacturer. Replace them with your own.

**Is it legal or financial advice?**

No. The templates are practical starting points for management decisions. Have policies and contracts reviewed against the law that applies to your company.

**Who can use it?**

You and your colleagues, inside your own organisation. Advisers need one licence per client organisation. Please do not resell or republish it.

## Working files from an experienced CIO, ready for your next meeting.
