Guides · Assess

Digital maturity assessment: template, questions and scoring

A digital maturity assessment tells a leadership team how far digital has changed the way the business competes and runs, and what is holding it back. This guide gives you a template to run one: eight dimensions, 32 questions, one scale and a scoring sheet, with a free Excel workbook that does the calculation.

Download the Excel template (.xlsx)Take it online, free

Both are free. No sign-up for the Excel file or for your online score.

What is a digital maturity assessment?

A digital maturity assessment is a structured review of how far an organisation uses digital, data and AI to compete, serve customers and run its operations, and of whether it has the capabilities to keep changing. It turns a broad question, "how digital are we?", into scores a leadership team can agree on and act on.

It is not an IT audit. Half of what it measures sits in the business: strategy, customers, operations and new business models. The other half is the engine behind them: data and AI, technology, people and trust.

A good assessment produces three things: a baseline the leadership team accepts, a short list of the gaps that matter most for the ambition, and a sequenced plan to close them.

It is most useful at three moments:

  • Before a strategy or budget cycle, to decide where digital investment should go.
  • When a new CEO, CIO or CDO arrives, to get one shared picture instead of one opinion per function.
  • When the board asks what years of digital spending have changed, and the answer is a list of projects.

What it measures: eight dimensions, two indexes

The Digital Maturity Assessment uses eight dimensions in two families. Each family has its own index, because two companies with the same overall score can need opposite programmes.

Value creation: where digital changes the business

  • Strategy & investment. Is digital part of how the business plans to win? Who owns it, how is it funded and is its value tracked?
  • Customer & commercial. How digital shapes the way customers find, buy, use and get help with what you sell.
  • Operations & supply chain. How far digital, automation and AI run the core of the business and its support functions.
  • Innovation & business models. How quickly the business tests ideas, builds digital offerings and works with partners.

Digital foundations: what makes change possible

  • Data & AI. Is data trusted and easy to use? Does AI run in production, with value and control?
  • Technology & platforms. Is the estate modern and modular enough to change quickly, at a cost the business understands?
  • People & ways of working. Do leaders and employees have the skills, the operating model and the habits to work differently?
  • Security, trust & resilience. Do security, resilience, privacy and supplier risk keep pace with the business?

The assessment template

You can run the assessment in a spreadsheet with the template below. It has three parts: the questions, the scale and the scoring sheet. The free online digital maturity assessment uses the same questions and does the scoring for you.

Download the Excel template (.xlsx)

Free, no sign-up. The workbook holds the 32 questions with the five answers for each, and calculates the score by dimension, both indexes, the stage, the profile and your three priorities.

Part 1: eight dimensions, 32 questions

DimensionFamilyThe four questions to answer
Strategy & investmentValue creationHow is the digital ambition tied to the business strategy? Who owns the digital agenda at executive level? How is digital investment decided and funded? How is the value of digital investment measured?
Customer & commercialValue creationHow joined-up are customer journeys across channels? How do you use customer data and AI to tailor offers, content and service? How much of your selling happens through digital channels? How is customer service delivered?
Operations & supply chainValue creationHow are core business processes run and improved? How connected are your physical operations? How digital are planning, sourcing and the supply chain? How digital are finance, HR, legal and the other support functions?
Innovation & business modelsValue creationHow are new digital ideas tested? Does the business sell digital products, services or data? How do you work with start-ups, technology partners and wider ecosystems? How does digital help you meet your sustainability goals?
Data & AIDigital foundationsHow is your critical data owned and its quality managed? How do people get the data and analysis they need to decide? How is AI used in the business today? How are data and AI governed?
Technology & platformsDigital foundationsHow modern and well run is your infrastructure? How easily do your systems connect and change? How is technology built and released? How is technical debt in the estate managed?
People & ways of workingDigital foundationsHow digitally fluent is the leadership team? How are employees building digital and AI skills? Can you attract and keep the digital talent you need? How are teams organised to deliver digital change?
Security, trust & resilienceDigital foundationsHow mature is cybersecurity? Could you keep critical services running through a major outage or cyberattack? How do you manage privacy and digital regulation? How are technology suppliers and their risks managed?

Part 2: one scale for every question

ScoreWhat it meansExample: "Could you keep critical services running through a major outage or cyberattack?"
1Nothing in place, or unknownUnknown: there is no tested plan
2Informal or ad hocBackup and recovery plans exist, but are rarely tested
3In place for part of the businessCritical services are identified, and recovery is tested every year
4In place across the business and measuredImpact tolerances are set for critical services, and recovery from ransomware and supplier failure is tested
5Designed in, and continuously improvedResilience is designed in: services degrade gracefully and recover within agreed tolerances

Score what you can observe today, not what is planned. If two levels seem to fit, take the lower one.

Part 3: the scoring sheet

DimensionScore today (1 to 5)Target in 24 monthsGapOwner
Strategy & investment
Customer & commercial
Operations & supply chain
Innovation & business models
Data & AI
Technology & platforms
People & ways of working
Security, trust & resilience
  1. Score each dimension: the average of its four answers.
  2. Calculate the digital maturity index out of 100: the average of the eight dimension scores, multiplied by 20. The eight dimensions count equally.
  3. Calculate the two family indexes the same way: value creation on the first four dimensions, digital foundations on the last four.
  4. Read the stage: below 40 is Initiating, 40 to 54 Developing, 55 to 69 Integrating, 70 to 84 Advanced, 85 and above Adaptive.
  5. Set a target for each dimension in 24 months, and rank the gaps. The three largest are your priorities.

Six reality checks

Scores describe capabilities. Six facts about money and adoption tell you whether the scores are believable. They are not scored; they are there to be compared with the scores.

  • Technology and digital spend. What does the organisation spend on technology and digital each year, as a share of revenue?
  • Share of spend on change. What share of that spend goes to change, meaning new capabilities, rather than running what already exists?
  • Revenue through digital. What share of revenue comes through digital channels or digitally enabled products and services?
  • Weekly AI use. What share of employees use AI tools in their work at least once a week?
  • Upskilling plan. What share of employees will be trained in digital and AI skills over the next 12 months?
  • Results of digital initiatives. Over the last two years, how have your main digital initiatives performed against their goals?

A high strategy score with a small share of spend going to change, or a high people score with little weekly AI use, is a finding in itself. The online assessment runs these consistency checks for you.

How to run one with your leadership team

  1. Pick the respondents. Start with one senior leader who sees across functions: the CEO, COO, CIO or CDO. For a richer view, ask three to five members of the leadership team to answer independently.
  2. Answer what is true, not what is planned. Each answer describes an observable state. If you are unsure, choose the lower level and mark the answer as an estimate.
  3. Set the target. For each dimension, agree the level the business needs in 24 months. Not every dimension needs to reach five.
  4. Compare and discuss. Where respondents differ by more than one level, you have found a blind spot. That discussion is often the most valuable output.
  5. Check the priorities against evidence before committing budget: the project list, the spend figures, the last incident, the customer data.

A self-assessment takes 15 to 20 minutes per person. Plan a 90-minute leadership session to compare answers and agree the targets.

Reading the results

  • The index gives the stage. It starts the conversation; it is not a verdict.
  • The two family indexes give the profile, which tells you what kind of programme you need.
  • The gaps to target are your priorities. Three is the right number: more than that and nothing moves.
ProfileIndexesWhat it meansWhere to focus
TraditionalistBoth below 65Digital is still managed as IT. Neither the engine nor the way the business competes has changed much yet.Agree a digital ambition with targets, fund two or three value-led initiatives and fix the foundations they depend on.
PioneerValue creation 65 or more, foundations belowCustomer, operations or new-business initiatives run ahead of the data, platforms, skills and controls behind them.Industrialise: invest in shared data, platforms, skills and security so that what works can scale.
BuilderFoundations 65 or more, value creation belowStrong data, technology and skills, but the business does not yet capture the value they make possible.Point the engine at a few business outcomes, each with an owner, a target and tracked value.
OrchestratorBoth 65 or moreDigital capabilities and business value move together, and digital is part of how the business competes.Push into new business models, AI agents in core processes and ecosystems, while keeping the estate simple.

The sample report shows the full result for a fictional distributor, including the capability heatmap, the 90-day roadmap and the board deck.

Common mistakes

  • Treating it as an IT exercise. Half the dimensions belong to the business. If only IT answers, the value creation scores are guesses.
  • Scoring the best unit, not the company. One digital-native business line does not make a digitally mature group.
  • Aiming for five everywhere. Targets should follow the strategy. A level of three, reached everywhere, often beats a five in one place.
  • Stopping at the score. An assessment that does not change next quarter's priorities was a survey, not a diagnostic.
  • Never repeating it. Run it again every 12 months to show the board progress against target.

Questions

Is the digital maturity assessment template free?

Yes. The Excel template downloads directly, with no sign-up. The online assessment is free too; your name and email are only needed for the full report and the board deck.

How is digital maturity scored?

Each of the 32 answers is a level from 1 to 5. A dimension score is the average of its four answers. The digital maturity index is the average of the eight dimension scores multiplied by 20, which gives a number out of 100 and one of five stages, from Initiating to Adaptive.

What is the difference between digital maturity and AI readiness?

Digital maturity covers the whole business: strategy, customers, operations, innovation, data, technology, people and trust. AI readiness looks only at AI, in more depth. If AI is the question on the table, use the AI readiness assessment template.

Should I use the Excel template or the online assessment?

Use the Excel template to work offline, to adapt the questions or to collect answers in a workshop. Use the online assessment for a faster result with a capability heatmap, investment checks, a 90-day roadmap and an editable board deck.

How often should a company assess its digital maturity?

Once a year, before the strategy and budget cycle, and again after a major change such as an acquisition or a new leadership team.

Next steps

The Digital Maturity Assessment is the online version of this template: 32 questions in 15 to 20 minutes, an instant index out of 100, your profile, a capability heatmap, investment checks, a 90-day roadmap and a board-ready PowerPoint deck. No registration is needed to see your score.

Assess your digital maturity See a sample report

Related guides